After seven years, Aerogramme Writers’ Studio is taking a break and it not currently being updated.

Click here to explore some of our most popular posts.

Teaching Creativity: Born That Way or Waiting for the Muse?

Teaching Creativity: Born That Way or Waiting for the Muse?

If you’re not born with creativity, do you have to struggle to acquire it?

By Josephine Scicluna, Lecturer in Professional and Creative Writing at Deakin University

Recently one of my Masters students, a filmmaker from the Czech Republic, told me his friends back at home were completely baffled that he was in Australia studying creative writing. You were either creative or you were not, they told him. It wasn’t something you could be taught. Although not voiced in such an emphatic way by my undergraduate students, I’ve still encountered many who hold the suspicion that maybe it’s all just fluff.

What I’ve come to understand is that teaching creativity is not about dishing out a set of instructions how to do it, but much more about helping students to identify the kinds of situations or conditions they need for this receptiveness to occur. From there, they can learn to harness this creativity in exciting ways. But first I have to deal with the resistances.

Much of the resistance I’ve come across bears the vestiges of an 18th-century Romantic view of the artist as a genius, “a one of a kind, a great original” as Margaret Atwood describes in her book on writing, Negotiating with the Dead (2003).

You’re either born that way or not. Or, you have to wait for inspiration, divine or otherwise, to hit you from above, below or sideways. In either case, creativity appears as something outside of your control.

Misconceptions about originality are another factor in my students’ resistance and this can create a real confidence block. If they emulate others, they feel that this doesn’t count as creativity or else if they can’t think of something “completely new”, they think they can’t even begin and freeze up altogether.

But, once you start to break down this perception, and help them see that creativity is a sensory response and always happens on the back of something or someone else, then a space starts to open up. Here, “originality” gets recalibrated instead into a unique way of combination. The aesthetic operation at work here – the making of connections between one thing and another – is at the heart of the combinatorial game that creativity is, placing an emphasis on structure which in turn refracts and re-inflects all that “borrowed” or “stolen” content.

Stop Thinking About It

One of the hardest ideas to grasp is the seeming paradox that creativity has little at all to do with the intellect. But saying don’t try too hard, or try not to think too much, is far too easy and not all that helpful. Instead, I ask my students to think about creativity as a kind of altered space and get them to think about what this feels like to them.

Everyone can call up an occasion when their experience of time felt out of kilter, or overheard a phrase that kept repeating in their minds with its own particular sound.

They might have been staring for hours at their screens trying to work but it was only in giving up and going to bed that creativity started to flow, just as their heads hit the pillow.

Or they might have walked into a building and felt their body react to the space in the sense that it is described by Peter Eisenman in his introduction to Elizabeth Grosz’s book Architecture from the Outside (2001). He writes of the affective somatic response that we have in architectural spaces arising from the virtual possibility of that architectural space, rather than from a perceptual or audible sensation.

Crossing the Line

All of these experiences could be seen as forming thresholds of creativity. If we can foster a sensibility or receptiveness to them, the creative space almost feels palpable. In this sense creativity becomes an “other”, but, of course, never completely outside space.

In class, I present students with an array of perspectives and “methods” with the aim of demonstrating that we can be creative by not even necessarily beginning with an idea. For example, by playing with language itself we can start creating something as Hazel Smith describes in her 2005 book The Creative Writing Experiment.

For many years now, I’ve been presenting a series of extracts of experimental writing about place, including Italo Calvino’s Invisible Cities (1972), which my students and I read together in class. Then I ask them to write about the street they grew up on.

The first time I ever did this I was struck by how much their writing had changed. Suddenly it was much more concrete, physical, located and more vivid than anything I’d seen them produce all semester. I saw an inclusion of the senses with a wonderful attention to the depth, breadth and height of the places and experiences they’d described. Also evident were traces of the initial extracts of writing presented for the exercise. These were combined into their writing in their own unique ways.

I could see their confidence growing when they recognised that doing an exercise like this created the space for creativity to happen. And it didn’t require an incredible effort.

For more from Josephine Scicluna visit her website and follow her on Twitter.The Conversation

This article was originally published on The Conversation; reproduced under a Creative Commons Attribution NoDerivatives license.Image by Brendan DeBrincat via Flickr.



  1. 4 March 2015 / 9:46 am

    This is so true. Creativity comes when the head hits the pillow so I keep a note book and pen at my bedside. I also carry a small one in my bag for those moments of inspiration or observation.

  2. 18 March 2015 / 1:57 am

    Great article. I like the point about sensory response and preparing the space for creativity to come. And I’m sure that regular practice will lead to an increasing number of moments when the muse visits you.

  3. 11 July 2015 / 6:07 am

    Love your article. These ideas apply to art as well as writing. As an artist and art teacher, you’ve given me more ideas for encouraging students when they complain they can’t think of something “completely new”. Interestingly, it only happens with the older students and adults, not the younger kids. Thank you.

  4. 14 May 2020 / 6:48 am

    A great article. I have read this for the second time. I haven’t read this completely because of the time but now I read this completely. Thank you for this interestingly written article.

  5. 14 May 2020 / 6:52 am

    An incredible article. I have perused this for the subsequent time. I haven’t read this totally due to the time however now I read this totally. Much thanks to you for this strangely composed article.

  6. Annie Garza
    15 May 2020 / 9:47 pm

    With a huge variety of products available at Impexlog Inc., we work to satisfy you shopping needs. You can purchase the quality products and amazing services at competitive pricing ranges. Our goals is to enhance the shopping experience of our clients with our services. Visit our website for more details.

  7. andiduferense
    3 November 2021 / 7:20 pm

    Do you know how to arrange home in neatly? In this article, the author shared some ideas for organizing items. You can try out these methods for arranging your room, at last, your room becomes neat and attractive. hi everyone

Leave a Reply